When the WandaVision trailer dropped last Sunday, some of the biggest teases came from the black & white portion of the show.
As I stated in another theory post, by the time we hit the 1950s portion of the show, we know Wanda and Vision just got married and have moved to the town of WestView. They want to fit in with the rest and they’re living their perfect suburban lives. At some point during the show, they will invite Mr. & Mrs. Heart over for Dinner. Played by Fred Melamed and Debra Jo Rupp, the Hearts will ask them all sorts of questions like; “When did they get married? Where did they move from? Why don’t they have children yet?”. Wanda stuttered when asked these questions and she wasn’t able to answer them because she didn’t know how to answer them. None of it was real. Vision tried to answer as well, but he didn’t know either. And that’s when all of their reality started to slowly fall apart as the aspect ratio started to expand. Now, something that really puts us at unease is when Mr. Heart slams the table and says “Dammit. Why?”, with Mrs. Heart telling him playfully to “Stop it.”, all while Wanda and Vision give each other looks of concern. Such weird things to say.
Now, when I asked you guys about how you thought Mr. & Mrs. Heart could be, many of you have stated that they’re actually demons sent by either Mephisto or Nightmare or people manipulated by the nosy neighbor Agnes aka Agatha Harkness:
Mephisto's demons ??
— EMPEROR BOSS (@GodEmperorBoss) September 23, 2020
mephisto and nightmare / mephisto’s demons https://t.co/i7bwTT4xIL
— jaye (@MCUXMEN) September 22, 2020
I kinda feel like they were normal but somehow got manipulated by Agatha to be negative and then get sent out/destroyed from Wanda’s world because they’re “negative” and all negativity doesn’t exist in Wanda’s world. I also see some people say they’re demons which makes sense too https://t.co/Kinlcxq7Ub
— mars ☆ razumovsky era (@MarsBarBelle) September 22, 2020
Now, these are all completely valid theories, considering how much Mephisto influences Wanda’s story and the birth of her children as a whole. Not only that, but we’ve also heard rumors regarding Nightmare possibly joining the MCU in this show and potentially manipulating Wanda to alter reality. But I propose another theory, and ONE of you actually got really close to what I was thinking:
Maybe I’m taking it too literally, but I take it to mean Heart is an indicator Wanda’s somehow trapped in her own body with this stuff — and this is Wanda speaking to her own desires, hence the questions about getting married and having children. https://t.co/HVW6wT24d2
— Adam Barnhardt (@adambarnhardt) September 22, 2020
And in that tweet was a reply from fellow Murphy’s Multiverse Contributor: Lizzie Hill, which pretty much consolidates exactly what I’m proposing today.
I suggest that Wanda is like a writer trying to work out details of this story, getting angry/frustrated on one side(Mr Heart), combined w/denial and trying to stay in the moment (Mrs Heart), combined with trauma of losing Vision & not being able to have this ideal life with him.
— Lizzie (@MsLizzieHill) September 22, 2020
And because Lizzie and I had a bit of back-and-forth regarding our theories, we managed to consolidate both our theories into this one theory.
THEORY: MR. & MRS. HEART ARE THE MANIFESTATIONS OF WANDA’S SUBCONSCIOUS
Something we need to understand is that during this show, a lot of the things we see in these homages to the sitcoms are actually the manifestations made by Wanda as part of her alternate reality. Meaning, the whole world around her is made up by her (except for some exceptions like Monica and Agnes, who are “intruders”). What if when Mr. & Mrs. Heart are asking these questions, it’s actually Wanda asking herself these questions, to quote Lizzie, “like a writer trying to work out details of this story, getting angry/frustrated on one side(Mr. Heart), combined with the denial and trying to stay in the moment (Mrs. Heart), combined with the trauma of losing Vision & not being able to have this ideal life with him.” What if they are the life Wanda wants for her and Vision? And with the way Wanda looks at Mr. Heart when he slams the table, it looks as if he struck a nerve in Wanda. Another possibility for Mr. Heart asking “Damn it why?’ could be her manifestation of Vision asking Wanda “Why did you do this? Why did you bring me back?” since we know that Vision is probably the only manifestation of Wanda that has any sort of control and when Mr. Heart asks the question and slams the table over and over, it keeps cutting back to Vision looking at Wanda, with Mrs. Heart saying “Stop it.” over and over in the background with Wanda looking concerned at Vision. Either way, it always just comes back to the same principle that this is all in Wanda’s head and it’s her ideas and subconscious questioning herself.